1869-1877 Dr. W.E. Beeson, D.D.
1877-1878 Colonel R. W. Pittman, A.M. (Acting President)
1878-1882 Dr. W.E. Beeson, D.D.
1882-1883 Rev. S. T. Anderson, Ph.D. (Acting President)
1883-1885 Rev. B. G. McLeskey, D.D.
1885-1887 Rev. L. A. Johnson, A.M. (President Pro Tem)
1887-1889 Rev. L. A. Johnson, A.M.
1889-1890 Rev. J. L. Dickens, Ph.D.
1890-1896 Rev. B. D. Cockrill, A.M.
1896-1900 Rev. L. A. Johnson, Ph.D. (Chairman of the Faculty)
1900-1901 Dr. S. L. Hornbeak (Chairman of the Faculty)
1901-1902 Rev. Jesse Anderson, Ph.D.
1902-1904 Rev. L. C. Kirkes, A.M.
1904-1907 A. E. Turner, Sc.D., LL.D.
1907-1908 L. E. Wear, A. B. (Dean)
1908-1920 Dr. S. L. Hornbeak, Ph.D., LL.D.
1920-1933 Rev. J. H. Burma, D.D.
1933-1935 Paul J. Schwab, Ph.D. (Chairman of the Faculty)
1935-1937 H. H. Leach, Ph.D.
1937-1942 Frank L. Wear, D.D.
1942-1950 Monroe G. Everett, D.D.
1950-1951 M. B. Thomas, Ph.D (Acting President)
1951-1970 James W. Laurie, D.D., M.A.
1970-1976 Duncan G. Wimpress, Ph.D.
1976-1979 M. Bruce Thomas (Acting President)
1979-1999 Ronald K. Calgaard, Ph.D.
1999-2010 John R. Brazil, Ph.D.
2010-2015 Dennis A. Ahlburg, Ph.D.
2015- Danny J. Anderson, Ph.D.